SUBSTACK NOTES IS FIRE

I’ve been on Twitter since 2006. One of the first 3000 users. I’ve spent a lot of time on there, and today I have 2,562 followers.

When I leave Twitter, I can’t take those 2,562 followers with me.

Now let’s say I spend more time on here with Substack Notes, and that leads to 100 new subscribers in April.

Then let’s say Substack becomes a dumpster fire in May.

I can export all my subscribers and go somewhere else. FAST.

The relationships I build are PORTABLE. I can export all my subscribers and open up shop anywhere in an afternoon.

That’s what makes Substack notes so remarkable; building relationships into subscribers, instead of posting on social media platforms for followers.

AT PEACE WITH MY PACE

Marlee Grace really sums it up here:

I noticed in my month off social media the ideation phase of my practice felt so serene, I had less money then and yet I still found myself with so much more trust. Left without the reminders that everyone else is always launching, always sharing, always has something to sell. I found myself peaceful with my pace.

YES, this is so great: “I found myself peaceful with my pace.”

I’ve stopped promoting Goodnight, Metal Friend on social media. Each new mix just goes out to newsletter subscribers first. A day later they go up on YouTube and Mixcloud.

Less promoting, and I still got a HUNTERTHEN track featured in this ‘Spectra-Sonic Sound’ mix.

Less promoting my HEAVY METAL EMAIL newsletter on social media, and I’m still welcoming new subscribers, and some of them support my work financially.

Trust that your work doesn’t need to be plastered on billboards, you don’t need to stand outside a venue handing out flyers. Let the magic go where it’s going to go.

SOCIAL MEDIA REACH IS OVER

I keep advertising in the newspaper yet I’m just not getting customers!
I keep buying banner ads but not getting sales!
I keep paying to BOOST my social media posts but nothing happens.
I keep spending time on social media platforms but not getting any reach!

When do we get the fucking clue? Take the hint.

Social media did not exist to send you free traffic in 2015, and it sure as fuck ain’t gonna make it any easier in 2023 – that’s EIGHT YEARS of beating our heads against the collective desk.

You saying you didn’t see this coming? Please.

Facebook pivoting to video in 2015 fucked everyone. Then oops, “Facebook Overestimated Key Video Metric for Two Years.”

So you think that same company that runs Instagram has your best interest in mind?
Think Elon Musk gives a flying fuck about your upcoming tour or EP release?

Bands and businesses flourished before social media, and they’ll survive without them.

MEG WHITE RULES

Imagine waking up and posting garbage like this:

The audacity to post “Meg White was terrible” to the entire world is beyond comprehension.

Meg White won four Grammy Awards
She’s in Rolling Stone’s ‘100 Greatest Drummers of All Time’ list
She’s a 3x Platinum selling artist.

You know what most normal people do when they don’t like something? They don’t think about it.

There are 1000s of bands and albums and song I don’t care for. Think I’m going to spend energy and time and effort and mental bandwidth letting the world know?

Nah.

This, though? This new album from Carmen Jaci is amazing, and I just pre-ordered it today (it’s out March 30th, 2023).

WHAT’S THE GOAL HERE?

One of the things I keep thinking we’re all going to “miss” if we’re not all on social media is the immediate satisfaction of posting something off the tops of our head at 10:32pm on a Tuesday night, and then seeing five likes and one person responds with an emojii.

That’s the dopamine hit. The rush. Insert your coin (write something, upload a photo), pull the lever (hit send), and watch what happens.

Over and over we do this, for fucking years. Half a decade. Or more. On different platforms.

We post, we hit like, we reply, and this somehow how keeps everyone coming back.

Because if we post something on our blog (like this), there is no response. I can’t see the immediate feedback, the reations, the comments (they’re turned off), the traffic.

I also think how if a few of us got together and started some sort of “group blog,” posting things through the day that we find interesting, it wouldn’t be enough.

We need to sit there, hit refresh, and see the new thing. The fresh post.

I remember the allure of the Christian message boards I used to frequent back in like 1998 or 1999. You’d hit refresh and there’d always be something new at the top, whether a new post, or a new reply.

With Buzzgrinder in 2001, I thought, “why not put the message board on the front page?” I mean, I thought I was smart shit, but the blog had already been invented! Hah.

But still, with a small crew we posted every hour on the hour, usually from 8am through 4pm, no matter what. There was always something new when you came back because we weren’t on websites for HOURS A DAY like we are now.

And hell, I made a concerted effort to avoid Twitter today and I think I was still on there like three hours total. Fucking christ.

And with that whole, well… websites just aren’t interesting enough to keep coming back to, that’s why we keep being pull back to social media.

Have we thought that maybe we weren’t meant to keep tabs on every news outlet, video feed, music stream, and entertainment stream all day and night?

How much is enough?

We’re already spending two, four, six hours a day on these sites. At what point does a social media platform come along that can match the pull? The rush?

I just don’t think we’re meant to be this connected to the fire hose of updates. I love my friends, but I don’t need to see the coffee they got on Tuesday afternoon, because I’m trying to keep up with 300 other friends, too.

But to what end?

At the end of the day there’s no destination, and the entire journey is made of fast food and cheap jeans.

GROWING YOUR BUSINESS WITHOUT SOCIAL MEDIA

I’ve been on a tear against social media for like, a decade or so, so it was refreshing to hear Amelia Hruby frame my distaste in such a new way.

(Also available on Apple Podcasts)

She really breaks down this whole thing about running a service business (coaching, editing, copywriting, etc) without using social media, and using actual, for-real selling techniques like emailing people, and talking to people!

Going that route instead of just throwing things up on the social media, and when the algorithms throttle your reach you can say, “well, I tried,” and blame the social media platforms for your lack of new clients.

And also – if you’re offering a service, you don’t want to scale. There’s only so many clients you can take on. Only so many hours in the day!

Like I posted on socials a few days ago:

Buy a domain name.
Set up a website.
All the stuff you shovel onto social media every day?
Put that on your website.

And here I am, a few days later putting that social media post on my website.

IF I’M MISSING I’M WORKING

If I’m missing I’m working,” as said by the mighty Chuck D.

Social media ain’t working, so in effect, you’re missing.

When I see big media outlets reaching just 3% of their audience, with full-fledged social media and marketing teams on staff? HAH.

As far as the 97% of your followers who haven’t seen that post?

You’re missing.

I know that’s not what Chuck D is talking about here, but he’s been off Twitter. Long enough for someone to say “you went missing.”

Nah.

He’s working.

Get working on things that work.

SOCIAL MEDIA LAST GASPS

This post from Cory Doctorow has pretty much ended it for me:

This is just what Twitter has done as part of its march to enshittification: thanks to its “monetization” changes, the majority of people who follow you will never see the things you post. I have ~500k followers on Twitter and my threads used to routinely get hundreds of thousands or even millions of reads. Today, it’s hundreds, perhaps thousands.

My biggest project is Heavy Metal Email, and I usually hype my recent posts on Twitter with some fancy videos or the cool images I make. Then I’m careful not to include a link, since that’s frowned upon, and I just mention LINK IN BIO.

Well, in the past month, I’ve gotten less than 20 clicks from LinkTree.

And that’s from Twitter, Instagram, LinkedIn, and Facebook combined.

So tonight I put out a new GOODNIGHT, METAL FRIEND mix (#32 right here) and I’m not going to promote it all via social media.

I’ve go a newsletter going out to 17 people at 8am tomorrow (subscribe here if you want). So they’ll get to see I have a new mix that I just released.

And I’ve now got 38 or so “followers” on Mixcloud, so those people will get notified of my new mix.

Eh, let’s see where it goes from there, because social media ain’t gonna help a bit!

NOBODY CAN COMMENT

Sure, paying someone to “handle you socials” is nice and all, but you can do the same thing with the format of your choosing.

Millie doesn’t have social media on her phone. Someone else handles her Instagram and Facebook pages, the only social platforms she hasn’t deleted, and she went to therapy to handle the constant bullying she has faced online. It’s hard to escape the fact that people are obsessed with everything Millie says and does. The actor has been inappropriately sexualized for years, something she’s tried her best to ignore, but the effect of trolling and harassment has been severe. Before she deleted Twitter and TikTok, Millie had been constantly bombarded with hateful messages, angry threats, and even NSFW missives from adult men.

Now Millie only speaks directly to fans via blog posts that read like diary entries on the Florence by Mills website. It works because, as she says, “Nobody can comment.”

NOBODY CAN COMMENT. I love this.

We don’t owe ANYONE a direct line of communication.

Want to make a comment? Eh, go start your own site, or post it on social media for no one to read.

We owe no one a conversation.

SOCIAL IS TRASH

So TikTok spied on Forbes journalists.

Twitter showing everyone how many times there posts have been seen. What a fucking TRAIN WRECK that’s gonna be for media outlets and labels. I’m sure this will be reversed by the weekend.

The UK based Center for Countering Digital Hate says “the TikTok algorithm takes just 2.6 minutes to show vulnerable girls videos touting restrictive eating plans and self-harm content.”

When anyone asks which social media network I’m looking to join next, I tell them NONE. I have this website. A few newsletters. An email address.

Bye.